Posts Tagged ‘VoIP’

Skype for iPhone Enables 3G Calls (& a fee)

Sunday, May 30th, 2010

The free Skype for iPhone (app store) was updated this week to version 2.0.0. Listed as new features are improved start-up time, faster access to the dial pad, enhanced call quality indicator and near CD quality for Skype-to-Skype calls. Oh yeah, and Skype over 3G. This feature has been on everyone’s wish-list since AT&T announced last October that it had “taken the steps necessary so that Apple can enable VoIP applications on iPhone to run on AT&T’s wireless network”. I thought it would be great, but it seems there is a new catch…. starting later this year, it will cost you a “small monthly fee”.

Skype is the popular VoIP software that has always allowed free video, IM, and Skype-to-Skype calls. Calling a standard landline, or mobile numbers, required you to purchase Skype Credits. It appears that is changing. Posts at 9to5 MacMacRumors and Mashable related to this update state that Skype-to-Skype calls over 3G are free through August 2010, but the Skype page in iTunes says “Skype-to-Skype calls on 3G are free until the end of 2010, after which there will be a small monthly fee (operator charges for data will still apply)”. I am not sure which is accurate, but a fee is coming.

I am not going to try and suggest that they can’t, or shouldn’t, charge for using their service, since of course they can. In fact, it would be easy to justify charging for Skype. It is very popular in the tech industry, and podcast world, and it is a great product. My question is, why only for 3G calls?. Is it simply a business decision on their end, or are the wireless providers involved?

Why should it matter to Skype where my bandwidth is coming from? It should not. If I am on DSL or Cable I can make Skype-to-Skype voice and video calls for free, but on the unlimited 3G data plan – I am forced into buying – I have to pay more? If Skype charged a monthly fee for their service, regardless of the connection method, that would actually make more sense. Charging only for 3G access seems like an AT&T charge. I might as well just use my cell minutes. OK, long distance may still come out cheaper on Skype, but the bigger issue is that this will change the image of Skype. Gone is the simple statement “Skype-to-Skype calls are free”. Adding the small italic text “*except over 3G where a small monthly fee is required” kind of kills the flow.

Before someone mentions that Skype is a business, and is free to charge for new features, I know that. Businesses are supposed to try and make profit, and I don’t mean to suggest otherwise. I don’t see opening a bandwidth option as a new feature. I see it as lifting a carrier mandated restriction, or removing a crippling feature. The other argument I have seen in various forums is that Skype needs to charge to finance their app development. A monthly charge was simply a bad business decision. There were options available to Skype to monetize app development that are more customer friendly than a recurring charge. What they have really done is create incentive to wait and use Skype on a different connection. That is not smart.

How could Skype better monetize the iPhone market? Simple. They could have implemented in-app purchases of Skype Credit. They could have even charged a small fee for the app itself. For me, I will simply wait until I am in front of my computer before I use Skype. The app is off my iPhone.

AT & T to Allow iPhone VoIP on its 3G Network

Tuesday, October 6th, 2009

ATT today announced that it had:

“taken the steps necessary so that Apple can enable VoIP applications on iPhone to run on AT&T’s wireless network.”

Up to this point, VoIP applications on an iPhone have been limited to running on WiFi, so this is fantastic news for iPhone owners. They have already notified Apple and the FCC. Based on the title of the statement, “AT&T Extends VOIP to 3G Network for iPhone“, this will be on their 3G network only. They have offered a variety of devices in the past that run VoIP on their 2G and 3G networks, along with WiFi, so I am not sure if this is for first gen iPhones or not. Doesn’t look like it. My question is why has this taken so long? The delay for MMS was said to be due to infrastructure upgrades, but since VoIP has been running on their network anyway, why was it ever – not allowed?

My problem with this is in principle. I pay for unlimited data…. except this, and that, and oh yeah… the other thing. I was lucky enough to buy NetShare in the app store before it was pulled by Apple. That lets me tether my MacBook Pro to my iPhone for internet access. Do I use it? Well Im not saying, but if I did it would have only been about 4 or 5 times when the WiFi at the radio station was out on a Sunday morning and I needed some web browsing. That would not be a huge load on the network. I feel the same way about VoIP. I use Skype. Not a lot, but I do use it. I also use Google Voice which, while not VoIP, does allow free SMS. I pay for a service from AT & T that includes unlimited data. To AT& T that means unlimited Email and Web Browsing. Unlimited Twitter. Unlimited Google Maps. You get the point. Unlimited anything that does not compete with AT & T services. I wish that unlimited data meant just that, any type of data.